By Jeffrey the Barak
I may be the thousandth person to publish a why I will be buying or won’t be buying an iPad rant, but here goes.
I am an Apple enthusiast, with a 27″ iMac, a white Macbook and an iPhone 3G, and I like all of them, despite the Macbook and the iPhone running slower than my needs sometimes demand, but I was determined to play with the iPad before automatically buying one.
The first few times I dropped by an Apple store, the crowds around the iPad table were three deep, but yesterday I had the area all to myself.
The interface and the display on the iPad were so beautiful and sharp, I felt like buying it on the spot, but I decided to stand there and try and perform some tasks over wi-fi first.
There are two things that make this something I should not buy. Firstly, it may be one of the lightest computers in use today, but since it is handheld, and not sitting on the desk, the meager weight of it eventually becomes a pain, and a warm one at that. This is no great surprise to me because I went through a tablet computing experimental phase in 2005 with an Acer tablet that had an awful display and an even worse operating system (Windows Tablet).
But the clincher for me was the iPad’s version of the Safari browser. It, perhaps deliberately, does not work well with Google. Yes Google, whom I love as much as I love Apple.
In my iGoogle home page, there were white bits representing modules that would not display, and in Google Docs, something my entire business resides in, the spreadsheets were kind of unusable in their “mobile” format. The iPad loads them as if it were a smartphone, and if you’ve ever tried to work in a big spreadsheet on a phone, you will understand torture.
So I will pass on the iPad, and probably also pass on any Google Android tablet that appears, for the same reason, but I will eagerly await the chance to get a Google Chromium netbook. I think that Chromium will be the key, and phone-based stripped-down operating systems like the iPad OS and the Android OS will only be useful for entertainment, as in photo viewing, book reading, video watching etc.
But to be fair, that is what the iPad is intended for, No-one said it should be used for real work first and fun second.
So a Google Netbook with a real keyboard is an exciting prospect to cut down on the weight of hauling a Macbook around, and I’ll gladly pay extra for a beautiful screen resolution to rival the iPad’s beauty of a display.
Such a thing should hit the streets later in 2010.
Jeffrey the Barak is an AppleGoogleTrout
UPDATE November 17th 2010
Well, I bought one, on September 30th and gave it six week of my time. Now it’s for sale on eBay because I cannot work on it. All I really do is work in email for eight hours a day, in Gmail to be specific, but Gmail on iOS is not so elegant as in OSX. Worst of all, my essential huge database, is a Google Spreadsheet, and even with the November Mobile Gdocs update, it’s a pig in iOS.So it will be a Macbook Air for me, unless the fabled Chrome Speedbook suddenly arrives and passes the rest. But I am not trying to be too negative about the iPad, it’s a superb device and worth it’s price. My personal needs cannot be served by the iOS, but I’m not the average guy.
I wrote this article on May 13th. 2010. Now it’s September 22nd. 2010 and I am considering getting an iPad. This week, Google announced it would be making a version of Google Spreadsheets that works well on the iPad, so that changes everything for me, the heavy user of Gspreads. Plus, Google’s Chrome OS is taking far too long. Now they are hinting at 2011 Q1, when everyone really wanted to have it by 2010 Q3.
So I may just grab an iPad and see if Chrome OS ever comes out on a very lightweight netbook with a long battery life. iPads are easy to resell after all!
An iPad was welcomed into my device family on September 30th. Google documents has not yet been changed to play nicely with iOS, but it will be coming. Even now, by installing an alternative tabbed browser, most work can be done on the iPad, in a pinch, when it is not possible to get to the full computer OS, but the evolution of lightweight devices into serious work machines still stops at the netbook, at least for today. The question is, when Chrome OS finally appears, wil there be a hardware option pleasant enough to make me move on from the iPad, or will it just be yet another additional category of things I need.